Nikon 35-105: Difference between revisions

Revision as of 17:22, 11 July 2021

An older macro zoom

This is out of the curiosity cabinet. I got this for under 50 used more for curiosity than anything else. It is a manual focus lens that can focus closer and have a reproduction ratio of 1:4 at 35mm and 1:5.5 at 105mm, letting you focus somewhat closer but not as much as what you are used to from a real macro lens that manages 1:1 or 1:2 ratios. In fact the Nikon 35 has also a reproduction ratio of 1:4. So technically it is hard to call this a macro, however it has two modes of operation, in one the minimum focus distance is more than a meter, and when you move to its macro mode, this drops significantly to about 30cm.

Working with a mostly manual lens is quite educational, but maybe a bit too overwhelming for someone with less experience (consider that 50 years ago, there was nothing better). There are a couple of things that this lens has, which I think is very helpful. The first is a hard stop for infinity. Basically if you turn the focus ring all the way to the end, the focus will be at infinity, which is what you want when you are taking landscape shots (and for astrophotography, but that is an other story). This is not as common as you think, even some manual focus lenses have this a bit less than the maximum. The second is the feel of the focus ring. Unlike some of the more modern lenses, the turn on the focus ring is very precise allowing you to focus easily. This is great as the camera is not doing it automatically for you. Oh and I also love the unconventional shape.

My Nikon 35-105mm f/3.5-4.5

Price	Very cheap
Weight	Moderate, 500g
Good for	Close ups, plants, daily
New or used	Not so common, but can be had for very cheap (under 50)

Full Frame

It is a decent lens for walking around and challenging yourself. Manual focus lenses require quite a bit of patience, they are not your typical click and shoot lenses, but dealing with such a lens is rewarding, once you get around the initial frustration. It is a bit of a longer version of Nikon 24-70 (and slower), so it can serve more or less all your needs, and will let you also come closer (not usual macro range, but still), very good for flowers for example.

APS-C

This is essentially a 50mm-160mm lens on an APS-C. While on a full frame it works quite fine, any cheaper kit lens like Nikon 18-105 would cover the same range and more on an APS-C, so it would certainly not be filling a gap you have. However, this is a very good lens for a day out, it does not go very wide or very long, but covers a decent range. It is a great challenge lens, you will need a bit of patience to get the most out of it, and where a modern lens gives you a perfect shot most of the time, you will have to try a bit harder. Only for those who want to experiment a bit, knowing full well that most zooms would easily cover this range and be easier to handle.

Gallery

Close focus at 35mm. Notice the falloff at the edges, and how at this shot, it actually sort of looks good.
Close focus at 105mm. This is about 80cm away, the reproduction ratio is 1:5.5, which is not that much of a macro to be honest.
This is to visualize the close focus at 35mm. This is what a regular Nikon 35 also manage by the way.
Judge the edge to edge sharpness on this picture. The focus is on the middle of the flower pot.
My dear furry companion [Tina the Hedgehog https://twitter.com/TinaTheHedgehog] shows off the portrait capability of this lens.
This manual focus lens has a hard stop at infinity, this makes it so easy to get such landscape shots right, but is not always the case with all lenses.
On an APS-C camera the wide end of the lens is actually not that wide, but it still remains quite usable.
This is to show off the sharpness of the lens, compare to the 1:1 crop from File:nikon35-105_flower_crop.jpg.
It is challenging to get your shots right with a lens that does not have all the gizmos of a modern lens. There is no autofocus, no image stabilization, and this is not a particularly fast lens at f/3.5, here in this shot stepped down to f/5.6. This is a 1:1 center crop from File:nikon35-105_flower.jpg. Usually the problems with your shots are not due to your lenses. I bought this lens for less than 50 (used), and I am not sure it could come out any better;.

These pages are for Amateur Photographers and not really for seasoned photographers and professionals. I have no affiliation or commercial interest with any brand/make. I write from my own experience. I ended up using mainly Nikon, so I am more familiar with this brand than others. See price for notes on pricing as well as photography related links.

@@ Line 14: / Line 14: @@
 This is out of the curiosity cabinet. I got this for under 50 [[New or used|used]] more for curiosity than anything else. It is a manual [[focus]] lens that can focus closer and have a [[reproduction ratio]] of 1:4 at 35mm and 1:5.5 at 105mm, letting you [[focus]] somewhat closer but not as much as what you are used to from a real [[macro]] lens that manages 1:1 or 1:2 ratios. In fact the [[Nikon 35]] has also a [[reproduction ratio]] of 1:4. So technically it is hard to call this a [[macro]], however it has two modes of operation, in one the [[minimum focus distance]] is more than a meter, and when you move to its [[macro]] mode, this drops significantly to about 30cm.
-It has a very solid build (and therefore a bit heavier) and quite a curious shape.
+Working with a mostly manual lens is quite educational, but maybe a bit too overwhelming for someone with less experience (consider that 50 years ago, there was nothing better). There are a couple of things that this lens has, which I think is very helpful. The first is a hard stop for infinity. Basically if you turn the [[focus]] ring all the way to the end, the focus will be at infinity, which is what you want when you are taking landscape shots (and for astrophotography, but that is an other story). This is not as common as you think, even some manual focus lenses have this a bit less than the maximum. The second is the feel of the focus ring. Unlike some of the more modern lenses, the turn on the focus ring is very precise allowing you to focus easily. This is great as the camera is not doing it automatically for you. Oh and I also love the unconventional shape.
 </div>
@@ Line 54: / Line 53: @@
 <div class="panel-heading">'''[[APS-C]] '''</div>
 <div class="panel-body">
-This is essentially a 50mm-160mm lens on an [[APS-C]]. While on a [[full frame]] it works quite fine, any cheaper [[kit lens]] like [[Nikon 18-105]] would cover the same range and more, making it quite unnecessary addition to your collection. I would not recommend it, if you want to have the ''challenge'' consider the manual focus version of [[Nikon 70-210]] for example, or a [[prime lens]] like [[Nikon 24]] AI-S. Notice that most AI-s lenses do not work on older [[APS-C]] cameras like the [[Nikon D90]].
+This is essentially a 50mm-160mm lens on an [[APS-C]]. While on a [[full frame]] it works quite fine, any cheaper [[kit lens]] like [[Nikon 18-105]] would cover the same range and more on an [[APS-C]], so it would certainly not be filling a ''gap'' you have. However, this is a very good lens for a day out, it does not go very wide or very long, but covers a decent range. It is a great ''challenge'' lens, you will need a bit of patience to get the most out of it, and where a modern lens gives you a perfect shot most of the time, you will have to try a bit harder. Only for those who want to experiment a bit, knowing full well that most [[zooms]] would easily cover this range and be ''easier'' to handle.
 </div>
 </div>
@@ Line 67: / Line 67: @@
 File:nikon35-105b.jpg|Close focus at 105mm. This is about 80cm away, the [[reproduction ratio]] is 1:5.5, which is not that much of a [[macro]] to be honest.
 File:nikon35-105c.jpg|This is to visualize the close focus at 35mm. This is what a regular [[Nikon 35]] also manage by the way.
+File:nikon35-105_flowers.jpg|Judge the edge to edge sharpness on this picture. The focus is on the middle of the flower pot.
+File:nikon35-105_tina.jpg|My dear furry companion [Tina the Hedgehog https://twitter.com/TinaTheHedgehog] shows off the portrait capability of this lens.
+File:nikon35-105_scenery.jpg|This manual focus lens has a hard stop at infinity, this makes it so easy to get such landscape shots right, but is not always the case with all lenses.
+File:nikon35-105_church.jpg|On an [[APS-C]] camera the wide end of the lens is actually not that wide, but it still remains quite usable.
+File:nikon35-105_flower.jpg|This is to show off the [[sharpness]] of the lens, compare to the 1:1 [[crop]] from [[:File:nikon35-105_flower_crop.jpg]].
+File:nikon35-105_flower_crop.jpg|It is ''challenging'' to get your shots right with a lens that does not have all the gizmos of a modern lens. There is no [[autofocus]], no image stabilization, and this is not a particularly fast lens at <kbd>f/3.5</kbd>, here in this shot stepped down to <kbd>f/5.6</kbd>. This is a 1:1 center [[crop]] from [[:File:nikon35-105_flower.jpg]]. Usually the problems with your shots are not due to your lenses. I bought this lens for less than 50 ([[used]]), and I am not sure it could come out any better;.
 </gallery>